Customer Experience Supervisor

AAMGA AssuranceAmerica Managing General Agency, LLC

Apply to this job
MCALLEN , TX Until 9/23/2026 3+ years exp First posted July 25, 2026 Last posted July 25, 2026
Job description

At AssuranceAmerica, we are more than a unique blend of insurance assets. We believe in creating a culture where every associate can learn and grow. We strive to create a work environment to meet associate needs and we are determined to achieve excellence in everything we do.

This is an opportunity to join a dynamic team in a company that is a leader in the non-standard auto insurance space and functions with a small company, entrepreneurial style. This position will require someone with an understanding that one needs to have a “roll up your sleeves” attitude to help make things happen.

The Customer Experience Supervisor is the leader of a team within the call center and fully responsible for all that takes place – from the design and establishment of protocols, to providing the management oversight to the Customer Experience Representative team members. Leadership is required to assure all calls are handled with utmost professionalism, in line with standards and practices, and managed in a timely manner to assure our company maintains a strong, positive image in the marketplace among our customers.

Each day at AssuranceAmerica is different, but as a Customer Experience Supervisor you will:

  • Guides and manages performance and professional development through coaching and mentoring of technical staff, including performance evaluations and salary reviews.

  • Performs regular file reviews and audits to determine compliance with best practices.

  • Facilitates and promotes consistent, positive Department financial results by actively strategizing with and providing appropriate guidance and authority to associates.

  • Requires technical knowledge and experience, including an understanding of coverage and minimum state requirements.

  • Responsible for various projects related to achieving Department goals (i.e., cost management, quality assurance, training, and development, etc.).

  • Control backlog error and expenses.

  • Knowledge of analytics and KPIs to analyze and evaluate associate and team performance. 

  • May be called upon to perform additional duties as needed.


Qualifications:

Required

  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent work experience.

Preferred

  • 3+ years of insurance experience within the private passenger market.
  • 3+ years of leadership, supervision, and training of others.
About this role

Summary

Lead call center team, manage performance, ensure compliance, analyze KPIs, and improve customer experience.

Job title

Customer Experience Supervisor

Experience level

3+ years

Minimum experience

3+ years exp

Industry

insurance

Location requirements

McAllen, TX; no remote work specified

Salary

Not specified

Management role

Yes

Skills & keywords

Required skills

performance managementcoachingauditinganalyticscustomer service

Preferred skills

insurance experienceleadershiptraining

Specializations

call centerperformance managementinsurancetrainingquality assurance
Locations

Structured locations inferred from the posting.

McAllen, TX, USA

On-site City